Faithful reader Danny pointed this out to me the other day.
On the new Scooby Doo Mystery Incorporated there was a character, Hebediah Grim, who is very similar to my own "Lord Salem".
The episode was called Grim Judgement and I guess the character was the ghost of a Puritan judge (thus the mallet).
I am not surprised they come up with a character like this. Using a Puritan judge or witch-hunter is kind of a no-brainer really.
I will have to watch this episode sometime and see if I get any ideas. Maybe for the game I can rework it into an CAH2 episode where the girls Lord Salem/Grimm are attacking actually are witches. Maybe this is the first time we see him.